When shopping for a used car, you’re bound to encounter the quintessential dilemma: should you buy a high-mileage car – and is it really a bargain or a burden?
In the UK, where the average car clocks up 7,400 miles annually, vehicles with six-figure odometer readings are surprisingly common. But does high mileage automatically mean trouble? And more importantly, does it make financial sense?
This blog looks at the pros and cons of high-mileage cars, why lower mileage options often emerge as the smarter choice – but also share the epic tale of #PassThePicasso, our beloved Citroën Xsara Picasso, which redefined what a “reliable” high-mileage car could be.
What Defines a High-Mileage Car?
In the UK, a “high-mileage” car is typically one that has driven 100,000 miles or more. That might seem daunting, but it’s crucial to remember that mileage isn’t everything. Factors such as maintenance, driving habits, and vehicle type play equally important roles in how a car ages.
For instance, motorway miles are often gentler on a car than stop-start urban driving. A well-maintained diesel estate that’s cruised up and down the M6 might wear better than a petrol hatchback that’s endured years of London’s traffic chaos.
The Tale of #PassThePicasso
Before diving into theory, let’s introduce you to #PassThePicasso, a Citroën Xsara Picasso that defied expectations. This humble MPV joined our fleet as a practical, low-cost solution. Over its lifespan, it racked up over 500,000 miles – a staggering figure even by high-mileage standards.
What kept it going? Routine maintenance and a touch of TLC. Oil changes were religiously performed, tyres were rotated and replaced as needed, and major components were serviced before they became problematic.
But the Picasso also taught us another lesson: while high mileage is achievable with effort, it’s not without its headaches. Over time, repair costs rose steadily – brake systems, suspension components, and electrical quirks became common concerns. And when it finally reached retirement, its resale value was laughable.
It’s a story that’s both a beacon of hope and a cautionary tale for buyers asking themselves, ‘Should you buy a high-mileage car?’
The Advantages of High-Mileage Cars
1. Affordable Pricing
High-mileage cars typically cost significantly less. For instance, a 2015 Ford Focus with 120,000 miles might be priced £3,000 lower than a similar model with 50,000 miles. That saving can make a big difference if you’re on a tight budget.
2. Better Access to Premium Brands
Ever dreamed of owning a luxury car? High mileage can make it feasible. A high-mileage BMW, Audi, or Mercedes-Benz often costs the same as a lower-mileage Vauxhall or Ford.
Example: A 2017 BMW 3 Series with 110,000 miles might sell for the same price as a 2017 Ford Mondeo with 60,000 miles. If prestige and comfort matter, high mileage can be a ticket to luxury.
3. Proven Durability
If a car has covered 150,000 miles without significant issues, it’s likely a well-built, reliable model. Many Toyota and Honda owners swear by their cars’ ability to cross the 200,000-mile mark with ease, provided they’re well-maintained.
4. Reduced Depreciation
High-mileage cars depreciate more slowly than their low-mileage counterparts. If you’re buying a car for the long haul, this can be a financial advantage.
5. Eco-Friendly Choice
Buying used is inherently greener than buying new. Opting for a high-mileage vehicle over a shiny new model reduces demand for manufacturing, conserving resources and energy.
The Disadvantages of High-Mileage Cars
1. Wear and Tear
Every car component has a lifespan. In high-mileage vehicles, critical parts – like the clutch, timing belt, and suspension – may be nearing the end of theirs.
Pro Tip: Always check service history. If major components haven’t been replaced, factor those costs into your budget.
2. Higher Maintenance and Repair Costs
High-mileage cars demand more attention. Routine services might turn into a series of costly repairs.
Real-World Example: A 10-year-old VW Passat with 130,000 miles may need £2,000 of repairs over two years, including brakes, exhaust system, and engine sensors.
3. Lower Resale Value
Selling a high-mileage car can be challenging. UK buyers often view high mileage as a risk, which can drive down resale prices and increase the time needed to find a buyer.
4. Potential Insurance Issues
Some insurers charge higher premiums for high-mileage cars, particularly if they’re older models. Always verify insurance costs before committing.
5. Uncertain Reliability
Even with a spotless service history, high-mileage cars are more likely to encounter unexpected issues. The peace of mind that comes with a low-mileage vehicle is harder to find.
The UK Perspective: What’s Different About High-Mileage Cars Here?
The UK’s unique driving habits and market preferences play a major role in the high-mileage debate – here’s why.
Short Journeys vs Motorway Miles
Cars in rural and suburban areas often endure shorter, stop-start trips, leading to greater wear. Conversely, motorway miles are less taxing on components. Always ask about a car’s driving history.
Diesel Dominance
Diesel cars, popular in the UK for their efficiency, are built to handle high mileage. A diesel engine with 120,000 miles is often in better shape than a petrol engine with the same mileage.
Rust Concerns
The UK’s wet climate and salted winter roads can accelerate rusting. High-mileage cars may have hidden corrosion – always inspect thoroughly, especially underneath the vehicle.
When Should You Consider a High Mileage Car: A Buyer’s Checklist
| Consider High Mileage If… | Avoid High Mileage If… |
| The car has a full service history. | The service records are incomplete or missing. |
| It’s a trusted, durable brand (eg, Toyota, Honda). | It’s a brand with questionable reliability. |
| You’re buying it as a secondary or temporary car. | It’s intended as your primary family vehicle. |
| You’re comfortable with potential repair costs. | You want low-maintenance, worry-free ownership. |
How to Evaluate a High-Mileage Car
1. Service Records Are King
Always ask for detailed service history. Were oil changes regular? Has the timing belt been replaced? These records are non-negotiable for high-mileage purchases.
2. Inspect the MOT History
Use the DVLA’s MOT check tool to review the car’s pass and fail history. Recurring issues can signal future headaches.
3. Professional Inspection
A pre-purchase inspection by a qualified mechanic is invaluable. They’ll assess components like brakes, tyres, and suspension for wear.
TIP: Test Drive Thoroughly
Pay attention to engine noise, braking smoothness, and gear changes. Any rattles or hesitations could hint at larger problems.
Back to #PassThePicasso: Lessons Learned from Buying a High-Mileage Car
#PassThePicasso wasn’t just a car – it was a character. From its humble beginnings as an economical MPV to its status as a 500,000-mile legend, it offered invaluable lessons about high-mileage ownership.
- Invest in Preventive Maintenance: Regular care kept the Picasso roadworthy far longer than most vehicles of its age and mileage.
- Know When to Let Go: Despite its sentimental value, rising repair costs eventually outweighed the benefits of keeping it on the road.
- Share the Journey: #PassThePicasso became a talking point for our team and clients, proving that even high-mileage cars can build a story worth telling.
Why We Recommend Lower Mileage
While high-mileage cars can be gems for the right buyer, we strongly advise lower mileage options for most UK buyers. Here’s why:
- Fewer Surprises: Lower mileage typically means less wear and tear, reducing the risk of costly repairs.
- Easier Resale: You’ll have a wider pool of buyers when it’s time to sell.
- Peace of Mind: Knowing your car has fewer miles makes ownership less stressful, especially for families or long-distance commuters.
So Should You Buy a High-Mileage Car? The Final Verdict
For adventurous buyers with a knack for maintenance, high-mileage cars can be rewarding. However, for most UK buyers, lower mileage is the safer, more practical choice.
When in doubt, remember #PassThePicasso – a car that went the distance but demanded effort and investment. If you’re considering a high-mileage purchase, arm yourself with knowledge, patience, and perhaps a trusted mechanic.
Or, better yet, let Palmdale Car Finders help you find the perfect used car.